Just in case you don’t feel like clicking on those links, our three rules for offing a character are as follows:
1) Would it be intellectually dishonest not to kill the character?
2) Is it dramatically the right choice?
3) Does the character dying have interesting repercussions for those left alive?
One of the examples we used to show the proper killing of a character was Ned Stark from Game of Thrones. As S wrote:
It would be incredibly dishonest and make the mighty Lannisters look incredibly weak if Ned Stark fails to die. And the drama in that moment is heart wrenching. Plus, so much of what matters in the moment of his death is how it will change the lives of his children, most importantly Robb. Everything about Ned Stark’s death accomplishes precisely what a writer (and reader/viewer) hopes it will.
So Ned’s death was a great moment in the story, and a great moment in TV. Unfortunately, as we were watching The 100 this past week, it occurred to us that other shows are learning exactly the wrong lesson from Game of Thrones. Rather than learning that killing a character can drive the story and provide motivation for the characters, it appears as if the writers of The 100 learned that it’s really cool to just bump off characters randomly for shock value.
In what’s been called the show’s ongoing Hunger Games storyline, characters like Jasper and Roan keep getting killed, not because there’s any logic or justification for it, but seemingly just because the writers want us to think “ZOMG! They totally killed that guy!” And then applaud them for their bold storytelling. The worst part is the violation of the third of our rules: there are zero repercussions for anyone left alive, and in fact the other characters barely remember those who died at all. But then again, that’s always been a problem for that show. See, for example, poor old…oh, what’s his name? It’s on the tip of my tongue.
Oh yes, Finn.
So that’s what’s been on our mind this week. In other news, S just finished posting her latest fanfic series, and the feedback from readers has been very good. So huzzah for her! And I’m about ten chapters into my latest Myrciaverse book, which might hypothetically be a birthday present for someone who might hypothetically be S.
Yes, we write stories for each other for our birthdays. It’s the unicorniest thing ever. So I’ve got to get back to that. In the meantime, let’s all hope The 100 figures out how to make character deaths count. I mean, I’m not holding my breath, but it could happen.